Recently a reader emailed me asking why I cursed in my YA books when she didn't think it was needed. I have had about 3 emails asking me the same thing. Keep in mind, this is 3 out of about 2000 emails I've gotten about The Mind Readers books. As I replied to the readers email, I realized I should just go ahead and post it, that way you can all understand, in case you've been wondering. So if you're interested, its below :)
I'm glad you've enjoyed the series, but sorry you didn't appreciate the
cursing. There are a variety of reasons my characters curse. I'll warn you, this
is going to be long, but you asked for it :)
-As an author I think its my responsibility to add realism to books;
readers have to relate in some way. Your niece and her friends might not, but
most teens curse. Keep in mind my characters are 17-21 in age. My characters
are, at times, running for their lives and as a reader I'd find it ridiculous
and unrealistic if they said something like "darn" while in a life or death
situation.
-I don't think cursing is a big deal. There are incredibly horrific things
that happen in this world and I think that a teen saying a few minor curse words
is the least of our worries. The other day I asked my cousin if the movie The
Avengers was okay to take my son to. I said, "fighting is okay, but not
kissing." As soon as I said the words I realized how ridiculous they were. It's
okay if my son watches people hurt each other, but a kiss isn't to be seen? I
think in this world we need to get our priorities straight and as I said, a few
minor curse words, imo, are not a big deal. Of course I don't expect teens to
curse in public places, such as while I'm eating in a restaurant, but that has
more to do with respecting other patrons than religion or beliefs.
-Cursing is a cultural thing. Some of the curse words we use weren't even
used in the biblical era. They are words that some man or woman in modern times
decided was wrong and banned. For instance before the Medieval era the word
Bitch literally meant a female dog and still does in some places. So who in the
world decided it was wrong? I'm not saying I use the word, but what I'm saying
is that you can't use the Bible to argue about curse words because some of
them just didn't exist at that time and some of them don't exist in other
cultures even today.
To be completely blunt what it boils down to is, as I said, it's not
something that concerns me nor does it concern the majority of my readers. There
are things like child molesters, sex trafficking, starvation, drug abuse that
concern me much much more than whether someone is cursing.
If I changed my book for every person and every religion out there, the
book would be a ridiculous combination of plots and conversations that wouldn't
be my own. I just read a book by another YA author and her characters drank
beer. That's something at this point I'd never do in a YA book. It has nothing
to do with my religious beliefs but with my childhood. I grew up with an
alcoholic father. In other words, its because of my own ideals and my own
background and I certainly don't judge her; I don't think its my right to judge
her. She did what was right for her and her book and her beliefs.
I started out as a writer for adults. My adult books are romance.
They're not erotic, but they are R rated, so for me the YA series is certainly
toned down.
I'll tell you something I haven't told anyone else, all of my books have
messages. Sometimes readers get them, sometimes they don't. I wrote an adult
historical romance called To Seduce an Earl. Some people might read that books,
see the cursing and the sex and think its a horrible book that should be banned.
And that would be too bad because the book is actually about finding redemption
and forgiving yourself, even people who have done horrible things. In other
words instead of looking at minor things like cursing, it might be better to
look at the overall message of the books.
Fortunately The Mind Readers is free so if readers read it and don't like
the cursing they don't have to spend money on the second book.
I will not change my book to accommodate a person or religion. Even if I
wanted to there's no way we can accommodate everyone and we shouldn't have to
try. But I can and will put in the blurb that there is minor cursing, that way
people know ahead of time.
Hope you understand, and I do thank you for your email and your concern.
P.S. The woman I actually wrote this email for never got it because her email bounced, which reminds me to remind you guys to make sure you type in your email correctly if you want a response! I get quite a few emails that bounce back. If you don't hear back from me, please feel free to email me again. If you don't hear from me again, then that means I'm probably ignoring you :)
As a Christian teen, as much as I'd like to believe that cursing is something that's not interwoven into the dialect of our culture, it's not true. Heck, i used to curse all the time. But I do agree, while most just curse because, you have done well in using it to add to the realism of the book. Also, on that note, I do appreciate the non-use of harsher curse words, just as a matter of preferance for me and my beliefs. Honestly, though, I'd probably still read your books. Keep doing what you do. Thank for sharing your creative mind with us :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Jakora, I'm glad you understand. It's like I said, I just can't possibly do what everyone wants. I wouldn't be able to write if I was worried about offending someone, because someone is always going to be offended no matter what.
ReplyDeleteI curse all the time and I must say that I got really annoyed reading the PC Cast books cos they did not curse as normal teens. Teens curse, even if they hide it at home they still curse. I want reality
ReplyDeleteDamn.... Just finished reading the series so I came looking for the Nora story.... And found this blog about cursing and I thought what cursing... I don't remember reading any... Maybe it is common place and I don't realize ... But any way loved the series... I just wished there was more... Like what happened to Tara or Maddock .... I usually want more from the story questions unanswered.... I I always feel like I left wanting more as if the story is not finished when I read books I love.... But I'll get over it slowly... Heheh
ReplyDelete